Billing as an NP: Incident-To Rules & Direct Billing Explained

Billing as an NP: Incident-To Rules & Direct Billing Explained

In today’s evolving healthcare landscape, nurse practitioners (NPs) play an increasingly vital role in delivering patient care. From primary care clinics to specialty practices, NPs often manage large patient panels, perform complex evaluations, and handle follow-up visits. However, while their clinical contribution is widely recognized, billing for NP services is still an area that’s often misunderstood.
Understanding the rules for incident-to billing versus direct billing is more than just a compliance requirement; it is the difference between optimized revenue and costly claim denials. Medicare and commercial payers have strict criteria for each billing method, and using them incorrectly can trigger audits, repayment demands, or even fraud allegations. This blog will break down both approaches, highlight their pros and cons, and show how to stay compliant while maximizing NP reimbursement.

Why NP Billing Rules Matter for Revenue & Compliance

For many practices, NPs are integral to meeting patient demand and improving access to care. However, the way their services are billed directly impacts the bottom line. For example:
  • Using incident-to billing correctly can result in 100% of the physician fee schedule reimbursement under Medicare.
  • Direct billing allows NPs to bill under their own NPI, but typically at 85% of the physician rate.
Practices risk underbilling, overbilling, or losing claims altogether without a clear understanding of when each method applies. The critical objective is to match the billing approach to the clinical scenario while ensuring meticulous, accurate documentation.
Why NP Billing Rules Matter for Revenue & Compliance

What is Incident-To Billing?

Incident-to billing is a Medicare provision that allows services provided by an NP (or other non-physician practitioner) to be billed under a supervising physician’s NPI for full physician-level reimbursement. But the requirements are strict:

  • Established patient & care plan: The patient must have an initial visit with the physician, who creates the treatment plan. The NP can then provide follow-up care that’s part of that plan.
  • Direct supervision: The physician must be physically present in the office suite (not necessarily in the same room) when the NP provides the service.
  • Scope of service: The service must be within the NP’s scope of practice and part of the physician-led plan of care.
If any of these conditions aren’t met, for example, if it’s a new patient visit or the physician is out of the office, you cannot bill incident to. In that case, you must bill directly under the NP’s NPI.
What is Incident-To Billing

Direct Billing for Nurse Practitioners

Direct billing means submitting claims under the NP’s own NPI number. This method applies when the incident-to criteria aren’t met, such as:
  • New patient visits
  • Changes to an established treatment plan
  • Lack of physician presence in the office
  • Situations where the NP is the primary provider for the patient
Medicare reimburses direct NP claims at 85% of the physician fee schedule, and commercial payer rates vary. While the reimbursement rate is lower, direct billing gives NPs more autonomy and avoids the risk of incident-to compliance issues. It also ensures the NP’s contribution is documented in claims data, which can be important for provider recognition and panel attribution.
Direct Billing for Nurse Practitioners

Documentation & Compliance Essentials

Thorough documentation is critical, whether billing incident-to or directly. Incomplete or inaccurate records are among the top reasons for claim denials.

 Key documentation elements include:

  • For incident-to: The supervising physician’s treatment plan, evidence of their presence in the office, and notes showing the visit aligns with the established plan.
  • For direct billing: Full encounter documentation under the NP’s name, including assessment, diagnosis, and plan of care.
  • For both: Correct ICD-10 and CPT coding, documentation of medical necessity, and signatures from the rendering provider.
Documentation & Compliance Essentials

Common Pitfalls in NP Billing & How to Avoid Them

Even experienced billing teams can run into errors that are specific to nurse practitioner (NP) billing. One of the most common mistakes is using incident-to billing for new patients, when these visits should always be billed directly. Another frequent error is the lack of documented proof that a supervising physician was physically present during services billed as incident-to. Practices may also fail to record which provider owns the treatment plan for follow-up visits, leading to compliance issues.
Incorrect code selection that doesn’t match the visit documentation is another cause of denials, as is overlooking state scope of practice rules that can impact billing eligibility. Regular staff training, internal audits, and the use of EHR prompts can help catch and prevent these issues before claims are submitted, ensuring both compliance and maximum reimbursement.

READ HERE: 7 Revenue Cycle Management Mistakes

Common Pitfalls in NP Billing & How to Avoid Them

How MaxRemind Helps NPs Bill Correctly & Get Paid Faster

At MaxRemind, we specialize in helping nurse practitioners and their billing teams achieve accuracy, compliance, and faster reimbursements. Our cloud-based EHR, integrated practice management system, and AI-powered medical billing tools are designed to handle the unique requirements of NP billing, from incident-to rules to direct billing processes. With smart claim scrubbing, payer-specific compliance checks, and built-in prompts for supervision and plan-of-care documentation, we reduce errors before they ever reach the payer.

Our solutions go beyond software. MaxRemind’s Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) services manage prior authorizations, appeals, and denial resolutions, while our EHR templates are tailored for NP workflows, making documentation seamless and audit-ready. Real-time eligibility verification, automated reporting, and integrated patient scheduling ensure your front desk and billing operations work in sync. MaxRemind streamlines the entire billing workflow, documentation, coding, claim submission, and payment tracking, so NPs can bill confidently, stay compliant, and receive payments faster, all without increasing administrative workloads.

How MaxRemind Helps NPs Bill Correctly & Get Paid Faster

TAKE A FREE PRACTICE AUDIT

Choosing the Right Billing Method for Your Practice

For NPs, understanding the difference between incident-to and direct billing is non-negotiable. Each method has its place, and the choice depends on clinical circumstances, supervision availability, and payer requirements.
By combining a clear understanding of these rules with the right technology and expert support, practices can protect revenue, maintain compliance, and recognize the full value NPs bring to patient care.

Bill Smarter, Get Paid Faster with MaxRemind

MaxRemind is here to help you navigate these rules with confidence so you can bill accurately, receive payments faster, and keep your focus on patient care.
START YOUR FREE TRIAL TODAY
FAQs
How does incident-to billing work for nurse practitioners?

Incident-to billing allows an NP to bill under a supervising physician’s NPI for Medicare patients, as long as all supervision and documentation requirements are met.

What’s the main difference between incident-to and direct billing for NPs?

The main difference is that incident-to billing reimburses at the physician rate, while direct billing reimburses at the NP rate, and the supervision requirements are different.

Can NPs bill incident-to for all payers?

No, incident-to rules are specific to Medicare. Commercial payers may have their unique guidelines.

What happens if an NP uses incident-to billing incorrectly?

Incorrect billing can lead to claim denials, audits, and even repayment demands for non-compliance.

How does MaxRemind help NPs with billing?

MaxRemind offers AI-driven coding tools, EHR integration, and end-to-end billing services to ensure NPs choose the correct billing method, maintain compliance, and get paid faster.